Birmingham researchers funded by Cancer Research UK and liquid biopsy company Nonacus have developed a new urine test for bladder cancer, which could reduce the need for invasive and time-consuming procedures to diagnose the disease.
The test will use highly sensitive liquid biopsy technology developed by Nonacus in conjunction with a panel of biomarkers developed and validated by Rik Bryan, MBChB PhD MRCS FAcadTM, and Douglas Ward, PhD, from the University of Birmingham’s Bladder Cancer Research Centre, to detect the presence of bladder cancer by finding DNA from tumor cells present in the urine test for bladder cancer.
The urine test for bladder cancer biomarker panel, which consists of 443 genetic mutations that are common in bladder cancer has been validated in a deep sequencing study recently published in European Urology Oncology.
In this study, which was funded by Cancer Research UK and the Medical Research Council, the researchers used the urine test for bladder cancer to analyze urine from 165 people with bladder cancer that had experienced haematuria (blood in the urine), and successfully detected the disease in 144 of them (87%).
The researchers also looked at using the test in 293 patients who had already been treated for bladder cancer and were being monitored for the cancer returning. In this setting, the test returned a higher proportion of false positive results compared to when used in the haematuria clinic (37.5% vs 15.2%), with 99 positive urine tests without a tumour being seen by cystoscopy on the same day. However, during their follow up monitoring, the patients who had those positive results had almost 3-times higher (11% vs 4%) rates of the cancer returning within 24 months indicating that the test could help detect recurrent disease before it is visible by cystoscopy (the camera inspection of the bladder). Further research is needed for the test to be used for surveillance.
“Even though cystoscopy is good at detecting bladder cancer, it’s invasive and time consuming for patients, so we need a better way to diagnose patients. In the future our test could be an easier way to get people with bladder cancer diagnosed faster, and could mean that tens of thousands of cystoscopies on healthy patients can be avoided each year,” says Bryan, the lead researcher.
The researchers are working in partnership with Nonacus, a provider of genetic testing products for precision medicine and liquid biopsy, to turn their approach into a clinical test for patients to be used within the NHS, and will start a clinical study funded by Cancer Research UK and involving over 3000 patients to evaluate just how powerful the test is at reducing the number of cystoscopies.
“These findings show that this urine test could help diagnose bladder cancer more easily. Early detection of cancer is key for improving patient outcomes and research like this could help identify the patients that need treatment soonest, while easing the pressures of diagnostic procedures on the NHS. We look forward to seeing how the test performs in the next clinical trial,” says Iain Foulkes, executive director of Research and Innovation at Cancer Research UK.
Each year, over 300,000 cystoscopies are carried out in England, however, around 80% of patients with haematuria who’ve had cystoscopy are found to have no cancers or abnormalities1,2. The researchers believe that using the urine test in haematuria clinic could reduce the number of patients requiring a cystoscopy by at least 45%.
- 312,447 cystoscopy test were carried out in 2019. Figure adjusted for 2021 working days. NHS England, Monthly Diagnostic Waiting Times and Activity Data for 2019
- Results from Khadhouri S. et al, BJU International, 2021. Data from December 2017 to December 2018 showed that 80% of study participants with haematuria (visible or non-visible) did not have malignant disease.