A Columbia University study has found that adversity early in life is associated with increased gastrointestinal symptoms in children that may have an impact on the brain and behavior as they grow to maturity.1
“One common reason children show up at doctors’ offices is intestinal complaints,” says Nim Tottenham, PhD, a professor of psychology at Columbia and senior author of the study. “Our findings indicate that gastrointestinal symptoms in young children could be a red flag for future emotional health problems.”
Scientists have long noted the strong connection between the gut and brain. Previous research has demonstrated that a history of trauma or abuse has been reported in up to half of adults with irritable bowel syndrome (IBS)—a prevalence twice that of patients without IBS.
“The role of trauma in increasing vulnerability to both gastrointestinal and mental health symptoms is well established in adults but rarely studied in childhood,” says study lead author Bridget Callaghan, a postdoctoral research fellow in Columbia’s psychology department. In addition, she says, animal studies have demonstrated that adversity-induced changes in the gut microbiome—the community of bacteria in the body that regulates everything from digestion to immune system function—influence neurological development, but no human studies have done so.
“Our study is among the first to link disruption of a child’s gastrointestinal microbiome triggered by early-life adversity with brain activity in regions associated with emotional health,” Callaghan explains.
The researchers focused on development in children who experienced extreme psychosocial deprivation due to institutional care before international adoption. Separation of a child from a parent is known to be a powerful predictor of mental health issues in humans. That experience, when modeled in rodents, induces fear and anxiety, hinders neurodevelopment, and alters microbial communities across the lifespan.
The study used data from 115 children adopted from orphanages or foster care before they were 2 years old, and from 229 children raised by a biological caregiver. The children with past caregiving disruptions showed higher levels of symptoms that included stomach aches, constipation, vomiting, and nausea.
The researchers then selected eight participants, aged 7 to 13, from the adversity-exposed group, and another eight from the group raised by their biological parents. They collected behavioral information, stool samples, and brain images from all the children, used gene sequencing to identify the microbes present in the stool samples, and examined the abundance and diversity of bacteria in each participant’s fecal matter.
The children with a history of early caregiving disruptions had distinctly different gut microbiomes from those raised with biological caregivers from birth. Brain scans of all the children also showed that brain activity patterns were correlated with certain bacteria. For example, the children raised by biological parents had increased gut microbiome diversity, which is linked to the prefrontal cortex, a region of the brain known to help regulate emotions.
“It is too early to say anything conclusive, but our study indicates that adversity-associated changes in the gut microbiome are related to brain function, including differences in the regions of the brain associated with emotional processing,” notes Tottenham, an expert in emotional development.
More research is needed, but Tottenham and Callaghan believe their study helps to fill in an important gap in the literature. “Animal studies tell us that dietary interventions and probiotics can manipulate the gut microbiome and ameliorate the effects of adversity on the central nervous system, especially during the first years of life when the developing brain and microbiome are more plastic,” Callaghan comments. “It is possible that this type of research will help us to know if and how to best intervene in humans, and when.”
Callaghan and Tottenham are currently working on a larger-scale study with 60 children in New York City to see if their findings can be replicated. They expect the results later this year.
- Callaghan BL, Fields A, Gee DG, et al. Mind and gut: associations between mood and gastrointestinal distress in children exposed to adversity. Dev Psychopathol. Epub ahead of print, March 28, 2019; doi: 10.1017/S0954579419000087.